Book reviews 3 & 4
‘A Clash Of Kings’ and ‘A Storm Of Swords, Part 1: Steel and Snow’, by Geoge R.R. Martin.
First things first, I’m so so sorry for the major delay in between my last post and this one!! It’s been quite a hectic few weeks with my job and clearly I didn’t finish these two books in time before Season 6 of GOT came out (don’t worry, I won’t Poe any spoilers about that in any of my posts … but Holy Crap it’s good!!!!!!), but without further ado, let’s get started 😀
Now obviously there are bound to be a lot more details in the novels than there is in the show, but I think the first book in this review really takes the biscuit when it comes to that statement. It’s almost 1000 pages long for crying out loud! I mean, that says it all!! But I feel the reader really gets to know the characters in this book. ‘Game of Thrones’ is clearly a wonderful introduction to this world, but ‘A Clash Of Kings’ really sinks its teeth in when it comes to developing the characters and broadening the readers perceptions of the world they live in.
Even if you’ve only watched the TV series, it’s clear that Season 2 is a lot more violent and fraught with danger than Season 1. In the novel, this is gone into with such detail that the more you read, the more you care for the characters. As readers, you get to hear from more characters in this novel as there is so much more happening in different parts of this world, and each character acts as an insight to what is going on in that particular area. We obviously still hear from Arya, Catelyn, Sansa, Tyrion, Jon, Dany and Bran, but with the expansion of the story we also hear from the likes of Theon, Davos and Jaime. This gives the reader insight to these character’s emotions and fears which really allows Martin to not only build on the characters he’s already created, but allows him to create additional complex characters who the audience unxpectedly grow attached to.
As for the differences between the show and the novel, there are not that many here. The most noticeable difference lies with Jon and Arya and their parts to play in the story. In this novel, it’s made clear that Jon and Arya both experience the same types of Wolf-dreams that Bran does when he throws his consciousness into that of his Dire Wolf, Summer. This indicates that both Arya and Jon have the capability to become wargs, Jon probably more so than Arya because he does seem to have a stronger connection with his wolf, Ghost. Arya’s wolf, Nymeria, was chased away by Arya in the first novel so she would avoid being killed by Joffrey, which indicates that their connection may not be as strong … But I could be wrong. I’ve heard many rumours about Jon’s and Nymeria’s parts to play in the story, but I don’t want to spoil the surprise!!! 😀 Another small difference in the novel is that Arya never meets Tywin Lannister up close. She only sees him once from afar while she is at Harrenhal, and then following the capture of Harrenhal by Roose Bolton does she become a cup-bearer. Also, Shae never becomes Sansa’s hand maid. Instead she is made to serve the daughter of Lady Tanda, who was assault during the riot in Kings Landing.
Something else I’d like to point out, which may definitely be an indication as to what is to come later on in the series, is when Dany enters the House of the Undying Ones. Here, one of the things she is confronted with is a human heart that is “swollen and blue in corruption” floating above a stone table, at which is sat one of the Undying of Qarth. Here is what is said to Dany at this point in the book:
” the shape of shadows … morrows not yet made … drink from the cup of Ice … drink from the cup of Fire … mother of dragons … child of three … three heads has the dragon … three fires you must light … one for life and one for death and one for love … three mounts you must ride … one to bed and one to dread and one to love … three treasons will you know … once for blood and once for gold and once for love…”
I’ll leave that open for interpretation 😀 …
As for ‘A Storm of Swords Part 1’, this was extremely similar to ‘A Clash of Kings’ in the sense that there are more characters in this book to bring the story forward and to give the reader a clearer insight to this world. In this novel, we no longer hear from Theon but instead we hear from Sam and about the advancement of the White Walkers. This is due to Jon no longer being able to hold up this side of the story as he has been captured by the wildlings. Again, I’ll probably be saying this a lot, but the detail is immense here! As Martin introduces new characters to forward a different part of the story, by this point in the series, the characters that have been used as regular points of reference (such as Sansa, Arya, Jon, Tyrion, etc) have become familiar and loved intensely by the audience. The detail that he goes into is key to making the audience care whether these characters live or die.
Despite this book being divided into 2 parts, the differences between Part 1 and Season 3 of the TV series are relatively few. The Wolf-dreams experienced by Arya and Jon are carried on here, and we also get a brief glimpse of Edric Storm, another one of King Robert’s bastards. Instead of the opportunity to marry Loras Tyrell, Maergery attempts to marry Sansa to her other brother, Willas. Sansa’s sudden marriage to Tyrion obviously puts a stop to this, and Tywin Lannister plans to marry Willas to Cersei instead. Bran met Jojen and Meera Reed in ‘A Clash of Kings’ and in this novel they are helping him use and control his warg powers as they journey to The Wall. And when Dany meets Missandei in Astapor, the girl she meets is just ten years old, not the fully grown woman we see in the TV show. Again, these are only very small differences, but for the most part the story has been displayed beautifully on screen. I thought it worthwhile mentioning these as you never know in the world of GOT when something insignificant can change the course of the entire story!!
Ok, I think I’ve rambled on a bit too much in this review, so I’ll leave it here! If you notice any other points in the novels that weren’t included in the TV show and that I haven’t mentioned in my reviews, please comment and let me know, no matter h small 😀
Until next time! Xx